The Pittsburgh Pirates are eyeing a veteran bat, but is it the right fit? Katie Woo and Will Sammon of The Athletic report that the Pirates are interested in veteran designated hitter Marcell Ozuna, a move that could spark debate among fans and analysts alike. But here's the catch: it's a tricky situation.
A Power Boost, But at What Cost?
Ozuna, 35, had a solid 2025 season with the Atlanta Braves, boasting a .232 batting average, a career-high 15.9% walk rate, and 21 home runs. However, his performance dipped in June, and PNC Park's dimensions might not favor his right-handed power. The Pirates' current roster construction also presents a challenge, with Spencer Horwitz and Ryan O'Hearn already in the mix for first base and designated hitter duties. Horwitz, in particular, finished strong in 2025, securing his everyday role.
A Defensive Dilemma
Signing Ozuna would likely shift O'Hearn to the outfield, but his defensive skills in the corners are below average. This move could limit the playing time of Jake Mangum and delay the promotion of top prospect Jhostynxon Garcia, acquired in a trade with Boston this winter. The Pirates' outfield defense could suffer, especially with the potential lineup of O'Hearn in left, Oneil Cruz in center, and Bryan Reynolds in right.
The Punchless Pirates' Dilemma
Pittsburgh's pitching staff is their strength, but their lineup has been one of the weakest in MLB for years. The Pirates might be willing to sacrifice some defense for offensive power, but it's a delicate balance. And this is where it gets controversial: the team's interest in Ozuna could be a sign of their desperation to improve their offense, even if it means a less-than-ideal fit.
Iconic Clash: Ozuna vs. McCutchen
The Pirates' pursuit of Ozuna raises questions about franchise icon Andrew McCutchen's future. Both are right-handed hitters who primarily serve as designated hitters. Ozuna has better numbers against right-handed pitching, but McCutchen, 39, has expressed frustration with contract negotiations this winter. The Pirates seem intent on adding a bat, but with limited options, they must decide between loyalty to their icon and the potential upgrade Ozuna offers.
The Pirates have made ambitious offers to players like Josh Naylor, Kyle Schwarber, Kazuma Okamoto, and Eugenio Suárez, indicating their eagerness to bolster their lineup. With Opening Day approaching, the Pirates are running out of time to make a move. Will they find the right bat to ignite their offense, or will they settle for a less-than-ideal fit? The clock is ticking, and the fans are waiting with bated breath.
